Call Now: (504) 305-8727
Call Now: (504) 305-8727
Concrete has been a popular choice for parking garage floors for decades due to its durability and strength. However, it does require more maintenance than asphalt – it needs to be sealed and resurfaced regularly in order to keep it looking good. It’s also more expensive and time-consuming to install compared to asphalt, which makes it less attractive to some people.
On the other hand, asphalt is known for its relatively low cost and quick installation process compared to concrete. It’s also easier to maintain than concrete – all you need to do is seal coat every few years which makes it an attractive option for those who don’t want to spend too much money or time on upkeep. However, asphalt can be prone to cracking over time if not maintained properly, which could lead to costly repairs down the line.
In this article, we will compare both materials side-by-side in order to determine which one is the best option for your parking garage floor. We will look at factors like cost, installation process, durability, and maintenance requirements in order to make an informed decision about which material will work best in your particular situation.
Parking garages are built with asphalt and concrete. Cement, gravel, sand, and water make concrete. It’s poured into forms and allowed to harden, creating a strong, heavy-duty surface. Asphalt, however, is made from asphalt mix and applied with a paving machine. Both materials have advantages for parking garage floors.
Cost is a major factor when comparing asphalt and concrete parking garage floors. Due to its heavy-duty components, concrete costs more than asphalt. Concrete requires more labor to install than asphalt, which can be laid down quickly with a paving machine.
Despite its higher cost, concrete outlasts asphalt and is more durable. Asphalt can become brittle from extreme temperatures or chemicals like gasoline or oil spills, but concrete is more resistant to cracking or breaking under pressure. Concrete is also easier to maintain than asphalt, which needs seal coating and cracks repair.
Both materials have pros and cons for parking garage floors. Before choosing the right material, each situation must be carefully considered.
After discussing concrete and asphalt’s benefits, let’s compare costs. Due to its components and labor, concrete costs more than asphalt upfront. Concrete costs 30–50% more than asphalt. Asphalt is initially cheaper, but it requires regular seal coating or patching, which increases maintenance costs.
Concrete outlasts asphalt for parking garage floors. Asphalt can become brittle over time due to extreme temperatures or chemicals, but concrete is extremely durable. Concrete is also easier to maintain than asphalt, which needs seal coating and cracks repair.
The best parking garage floor material should be durable. Concrete is stronger than asphalt, making it the preferred material for heavy wear and tear. Concrete resists cracking and breaking under pressure, making it ideal for heavy traffic or weight loads. However, extreme temperatures or chemicals can make asphalt brittle, requiring regular seal coating or patching.
Concrete is stronger than asphalt and requires less maintenance. Its strength and durability make it ideal for parking garages because it can withstand heavy traffic without needing frequent repair or replacement like asphalt. Since cracks don’t need to be repaired, owners save money on long-term maintenance.
Installation, maintenance, and durability must be considered when choosing a parking garage floor material. Before choosing a material for these floors, carefully evaluate the pros and cons of concrete and asphalt. Concrete beats asphalt due to its strength and low maintenance.
Concrete is better for parking garage floor maintenance. Concrete doesn’t need to be sealed or patched like asphalt because it cracks less under pressure. By avoiding surface repairs, owners can save money on long-term maintenance. Concrete only needs periodic sweeping and mopping to maintain its appearance.
Asphalt needs regular sealing and patching to stay in good condition. To prevent further damage, fill cracks or holes caused by heavy loads or extreme temperatures with an asphalt-based sealant. Many prefer concrete because more repairs can be costly.
Both materials have benefits when building parking garage floors. Asphalt is cheaper to install than concrete, but it requires more maintenance, making it less appealing for low-maintenance solutions. Concrete is best for those who want a long-lasting, low-maintenance solution.
Noise reduction is another consideration when choosing concrete or asphalt for parking garage floors. Concrete reduces garage noise more than asphalt.
Concrete is best for garage soundproofing because it absorbs sound waves better than asphalt. Concrete can also be laid in patterns to absorb sound, making the environment quieter. Asphalt, however, has harder surfaces that reflect and amplify sound.
Depending on the results, both materials are cost-effective. If a homeowner wants better noise reduction, they may have to pay more for thicker asphalt layers or choose concrete, which is more expensive. To maximize investment value, homeowners must consider all factors when making this decision.
Concrete and asphalt parking garage floors differ in noise reduction and environmental impact. Concrete has environmental advantages over other materials, such as using recycled materials and low-carbon production methods.
Concrete is more sustainable than asphalt because it doesn’t use petroleum. Concrete absorbs atmospheric carbon dioxide, making it a good choice for carbon reduction. Recyclable concrete reduces emissions and waste.
Asphalt’s recycled materials make it sustainable. Asphalt production emits glasshouse gases, so it may not be as environmentally friendly as concrete.
When choosing between asphalt and concrete parking garage floors, consider the environment. Concrete’s ability to absorb carbon dioxide and reuse make it a better choice overall.
Concrete and asphalt are fire-resistant. Concrete is fireproof, unlike asphalt. Steel reinforcement can boost concrete’s fire rating. However, asphalt can protect against fires if maintained.
For smaller projects, asphalt is cheaper than concrete. Asphalt requires less maintenance than concrete, making it a cheaper long-term option. In large projects like parking garages, concrete’s strength and durability may make up for its higher initial cost.
Both materials are fire-resistant, but each has pros and cons depending on your project. Before choosing concrete or asphalt for your parking garage floors, consider budget, longevity, and aesthetics.
In conclusion, when deciding between concrete and asphalt for a parking garage floor, there are many factors to consider. It’s important to look at the installation time, cost-effectiveness, noise reduction, fire resistance, and structural integrity of each material. Depending on your needs, one material may be better than the other.
Concrete is typically more expensive than asphalt but can last longer if properly maintained. Asphalt is generally faster and cheaper to install but may need to be replaced more often due to wear and tear. Both materials offer good fire resistance and can be designed with certain structural considerations in mind.
Ultimately, it comes down to personal preference and budget. Concrete may be better suited for long-term projects while asphalt might make more sense for short-term solutions or those on a tighter budget. Whatever you choose, make sure you do your research before making a decision that works best for you.
By Big Easy Flooring 
Feb 17, 2023